357 magnum ammo types

February 22, 2021 No comments exist

Maybe I am reading it wrong, but on the Fiocchi 145 grain you state in the general stats that it “is reloadable like the other cartridges on this list…”. This is a variable in calculating and delivering mass on target through kinetic energy transfer. JSP will work in anything as long as it's the correct loading for the gun. Hi Matt, Best bet for practice in a defensive mode is 38 Special 125 gr. More than that, the debate about what is and is not a proper penetration depth and performance is a heated discussion at most times. Simple cartridge made to preserve the original loadings of the round. There is a debate on this point. Copyright © 2021 Pew Pew Media, Inc. All rights reserved. Any .357 magnum and .38 special ammo will work in both revolvers and rifles. All objects like bullets with neglible air drag coefficients, "drop" at the rate of 32 ft/sec². ammo. 211740050 Hexagon 357 Magnum 180 Grain Hexagon 50 Rounds [21174005076] View Out. While this is a highly debated subject it’s beyond the scope of this article, except to say, that there has been compelling data to show that some animals are given an almost instantaneous death due to a bullet traveling above a certain speed and increasing the chance for devastating consequences related to the impact a high speed projectile has on a target with a high volume of liquids. According to Ruger, this creates a maximum lethal hydraulic displacement in human tissue upon impact by the way the flutes in the projectile expand outward, delivering energy laterally in surrounding tissue, in addition to head-on. The hard-hitting copper bullet still offers maximum stopping power despite being lighter weight than some competing projectiles. Ammunition is made to certain specifications, size and pressure. I have a quick question. LEVERevolution ® represents a breakthrough in ammo design for lever action rifles and revolvers. Find your best price for 357 Mag Ammo | Best 357 Mag Ammunition - AmmoSeek.com Search Engine 2021 357 load. It shoots a 110 Grain bullet at a muzzle velocity of 995 fps. that has the capabilities to injure or kill. immediately became a ... the most common type of firearm built to handle the Mangum is the double-action revolver. Meaning if you have a revolver chambered in .357, you can fire both ammo types without any issues. The recoil of this lighter weight round is almost intolerable and the muzzle flips up dangerously. Then practice. I HAVE JUST LOOKED OVER THE INFORMATION ON THE 357 AMMO. It is the best IF it's used in a 6" barrel revolver, such as a Colt Python, or a Manhurin M73 - both very pricey guns, but the key to maximum performance is the 6" barrel. Unless you are shooting multiple times per week, I suggest you run a few patches down and wipe it off. Shop online for top quality .357 Magnum Centerfire Handgun Ammo for sale! is an excellent round. If the Tripwire is set to zero (0 or 0.00), it is considered OFF - meaning the alarm will sound if any item in the current tracker shows "In Stock" regardless of cost per round.. To turn ON the Tripwire, just enter a value you are willing to pay for each round of ammunition. It shoots a 158 Grain bullet at a muzzle velocity of 1235 fps. This has been proven to be less effective than some other aspects of projectile performance, as the diameter sometimes does little more to cause more trauma or decrease the time it takes to stop a target. . The value for your shooting dollar is exceptionally high and the performance has been market leading since it was introduced in the 1930’s. I'm not sure if you have a revolver or an automatic pistol, but that's a simple mistake for a new shooter or a big box store clerk to make. Hello Speer Gold Dot Short Barrel Ammunition 357 Magnum - 135 Grain Jacketed Hollow Point. The .357 Mag. I have a question about ammo. Follow these tips, get in some trigger time with a few different rounds, and you’ll be just fine. Lighter bullets have slower bullet drops, which can increase accuracy over long distances. shoots a 125 Grain bullet at a muzzle velocity of 1220 fps. 45 hp; 5.75 velodog; 320 short; 32 s&w short; 7.63 mauser; 7.65 parabellum; 9 makarov; 32 s&w long; 7.62 nagant; 7.5 swiss ordinance; 8mm lebel; 9mm steyr; 380 short; 380 long; 8mm gasser; 38 s&w short; 450 short; 44 s&w russian; 455 webley; 7.62 tokarev; 10 auto; 25 auto; 32 auto; 44 special; 45 colt; 8mm steyr While there is considerable controversy over whether heavier bullets are better than light ones, in reality, different situations need different bullets. . I still like to steer towards standard law enforcement rounds for self defense. This side seems to have the most acceptance, and I don’t mean to suggest that this bit of conventional wisdom didn’t come from somewhere. This ammunition is new production, non-corrosive, boxer primed, in … The agencies and officers nearly all, preferred to have less rounds of the .357 Magnum than the 1911 based .38 Super and revolver based .38 Special rounds because of the inherent power and stopping power. Shooting this round can be a little dirty though, so gun cleaning is mandatory after each shooting session. It is a good small game or varmint round. The total amount of weight that a projectile holds. HSM Cowboy Action Ammunition. Lightweight Bullet Characteristics 357 Magnum Ammo. If it is the right ammo and won’t fit a revolver then something is wrong with the ammo. This is the round I load in my.38’s. Regarding Heavy Bullets, you say: "The speed at which [a heavy bullet] hits the ground or “bullet drop” is faster than for a light bullet." It has a muzzle velocity of 938 fps. 357 magnum ammo for sale that's in stock at Xtreme Guns And Ammo - today! The soft point is a solid round so it will penetrate the tough animal hide (deer) and still drive deep enough for a kill. Underwood. Just a thought. The lighter and therefore faster bullet will expand more violently to the point of fragmentation, bullet construction being equal and arrest sooner than a heavier and slower bullet that retains it weight. https://www.luckygunner.com/labs/revolver-ballistics-test/ purchase helps support my work in bringing you more awesome gun and gear articles. It is a loaded field of competitors because it is one of the most popular rounds in the United States and it enjoys a very good reputation for performance that is still able to be handled adequately by most shooters. Thank you , and I'll say it again , .............Great Article !! Follow these tips, get in some trigger time with a few different rounds, and you’ll be just fine. Critics often view hunting as a means to kill animals for fun or sport. I think this starts to reverse as you decrease in caliber. Both of these revolvers have the same bullet diameter of .357 inch but the .357 Magnum has a slightly longer case. Excellent article. Given the same flight time, the only difference is the distance covered before hitting the target/ground. a steel case so sometimes it might not eject easily for your revolver. Hakim & Rasheed Carbine [Review]. Very rarely will you go wrong. This cartridge started the “Magnum era” of handgun ammunition. The 38+P has excellent 357 Remington Magnum Ammunition For Sale Caliber/Gauge: 357 Remington Magnum, Condition: Factory New Reset Selection for Product Types Ammunition (111) Ammunition (111) The recoil is mild compared to most rounds available and the performance is excellent with the all-lead semi wadcutter which shows well on paper targets and offers easy shooting. The thing is that its been successful but at its original design velocity of 1450 fps . Any other ammo suggestions for home defense, plinking, or hunting? I was pretty surprised that barrel length didn't play as big of a role as I imagined it would. More energy retention. It was created by Elmer Keith, Phillip B. Sharpe,and D. B. Wesson[4] of firearms manufacturers Smith & Wesson and Winchester. Using the wrong ammo can cause you to flinch, breathe wrong, or even close your eyes while firing. Featuring cheap .357 mag ammunition and bulk 357 magnum ammo. Choosing .357/.38 Special Ammo for Hunting. The Lead Round Nose (LRN) refers to a bullet that has a smooth curve at the top. The .357 Magnum is a versatile cartridge with a ton of options. This is an ability that cartridges like 9mm,.45ACP and others can’t match. Subscribe to Pew Pew Tactical's sales and deals email. He is also an avid competitor, reloader, and all-around firearms aficionado who can help you learn more about almost every aspect of shooting and caring for firearms. It shoots a 158 Grain bullet at a velocity of 755 fps. Penetrating deep, but also fragmenting at certain harder internals like bone, to create max. For hunting smaller varieties of game 50 lbs. I just bought myself a couple of Ruger Vaqueros and a Henry rifle all in .357 and was looking for good bullet info. For beginners, it is just as important to choose ammo that has the least possible recoil. The .357 magnum 125gr hollow-points have been recognized as the best round for self-defense . End Human Trafficking. Risk Management. Revolvers were cool in the days of Wild Bill Hickok and they’re still cool now. To help keep the price down this bullet uses. Any thoughts on Ruger ARX ammo for self-defense? Reproduction of any portion of this website only at the permission of GunandShooter. Product Name Price Latest Products Most Popular. If you found any image copyrighted to yours, please contact us, so we can remove it. Hunters everywhere have used it as a secondary backup firearm on big hunts or as a primary handgun or lever gun for intermediate sized game at intermediate and shorter ranges for decades. Home Defense and Personal Defense in a Carry situation, when you need the ultimate in stopping power and need ultimate reliability and are aware of the surroundings. Check Price. It is a direct measure of the effect of drag on a projectile size, weight, shape and profile, Deformation/mushrooming/expanded diameter. I was sold 357 jsp and It didn’t fit the handgun. The ammo will need to produce a lot of energy to produce the greatest amount of tissue damage and trauma. (Perhaps a simple error, but a crucial one!) Unless your revolver doesn’t work with ammo from different companies then it’s a problem with the gun; which is rare but can happen. It was created by Elmer Keith, Phillip B. Sharpe, and Douglas B. Wesson of firearms manufacturers Smith & Wesson and Winchester.. Penetration varies on different targets. Bullet Style: Hornady XTP Jacketed Hollow Point You do not pay anything extra and your The. Let’s go over some common terminology first before diving into the best .38 Special and .357 Magnum ammo for home defense, target shooting, and hunting. It is a good varmint hunting round that I have used in the past. It shoots a 158 Grain FMJ bullet at a muzzle velocity of 1280 fps. I recently nearly bought a bought a box of .357 Sig by accident instead of .357 Mag and I’m not a newbie so, it can happen. you do a pretty good job at explaining all this. The bullets used for self defense are a bit more expensive than the ones you would use for target practice. But this is my choice for many different situations including self , or home defense, but I do not hunt with a hand gun from personal choice. I shot up two boxes of the Fiocchi 142gr FMJ .357 rounds this weekend. Description Grains FPS Rounds Price PPR. There is a photo above with a caption reading "For cool photographic purposes only. Page 1 of 1. Pro Ammo Tip #2: Know Your Bullet Weight and Why It Matters. But make sure you are not using .38-40 or .38 Short. Stick to well known, large and trusted companies that produce ammunition. Shop discount prices on .357 Magnum Pistol Ammo at Sportsman's Guide. 2. and under I have used a .38 Special revolver. Terms of Service apply. As I stated I have been a gun dealer as well as a gun owner since age 5 and I still own my .357 Ruger New Model Blackhawk, and my wife has her 6 inch Smith and Wesson Model 28 .357 mag Highway Patrolman she picked out for her self which I had sold out of my gun shop in 1979 and bought back here in Oregon in 1989 for $25.00 more than I sold it for, and I had personally done the trigger work on this revolver before I sold it, but i was always taught that heavier bullets penetrate deeper as the mass retains speed better than lighter weight rounds. Hide Reman Hide Steel . You left out the best for hunting. I like it because it has a low recoil and will not frighten new shooters. I chose the 24o grain for its long range accuracy, however it is a 'wow" experience to shoot. All the projectiles in the cartridge on this list are at a penetration depth which is within the depth of penetration that the FBI sets as a standard for the best defense and Duty ammunition. In my Model 36 Chief's Special, whenever I fired more than one box of 158 gr +P HP rounds. It has a high stopping power and enough penetration power to shoot through many kinds of body armor. — 90 products / 94 models Get a more uniform and reliable shot with the superior shotgun 357 Magnum Ammunition. The best .357 magnum ammo for each use case is outlined above. Another excellent round for whitetail-sized game. I must have missed yours first time through. Technical Information, Caliber: 357 Magnum Revolvers that shoot the .357 Magnum can also shoot the .38 Special. It has a muzzle velocity of 800 fps. Thanks again. I calculated roughly an energy at the muzzle of 800+ ft. lbs. Very straightforward and minus all the caveats and disclaimers. It is excellent for target or as a training bullet. projectile. i was also taught heavier rounds kick more as it takes more powder to get the heavy lead moving even if it not as fast as the lighter round. It's been my experience that a heavier bullet tends to go deeper than a lighter one. Heavy Bullet Characteristics The .38 SPL +P HP is a fine round-in a model 10 4" gun. It is a high terminal performance bullet. Hi Ryan, I've shot them at range days but it wasn't at gelatin or anything. Mostly, the .357 magnum is known for its prowess as a duty cartridge for law enforcement and as a potent cartridge for personal defense and home protection, where the fast projectile can penetrate deeply enough and create a large enough transfer of energy so as to immediately stop most threats. heavier) bullets. The .357 Magnum cartridge is notable for its highly effective terminal ballistics when used for hunting or defense. That's something required in many areas if a bite has occurred (depends on if it's vaccinated or not). This is the culmination of 150+ years of experience in developing self-defense and duty ammunition and Winchester has pulled out all the stops to deliver a product that is super premium, with a performance that most other cartridges are jealous of. The ammo will need to produce a lot of energy to produce the greatest amount of tissue damage and trauma. A revolver will load any ammo it was made for. Home Defense , Self Defense .357 Magnum , ammo , home defense , lever-action , revolver , self-defense , Smith & Wesson Permalink The rifle is loaded through gate on the right side and up to fourteen rounds of .357 Magnum ammunition can be … Case Type: Ducta-Bright 7a Nickel Plated Brass, Muzzle Velocity: 1700 fps I see a trend towards lighter ammunition , and I suppose it's due to advanced bullet design . with a .357 Magnum revolver I would use a bullet weight of at least 158 to 180 Grains with a heavy powder charge. Never use full metal jacket bullets because they may pass through the animal without a humane kill. It is comprised of the velocity and the energy delivery at the muzzle exit point, before significant wind drag or other environmental effects can degrade the power of the bullet. Good article. Sure you can shoot 357 from a sub 30 oz pistol rated for it but you're gonna feel it and you will not want to train with 357 using that pistol. The high velocity and high energy transfer with the penetration and modern designed projectiles (more on that later), which offer high weight retention, this is a perfect cartridge for many types of game. The barrel becomes a part of the chamber as the bullet advances, and with pistols having sort barrels, not all of the powder is burned before the bullet exits the barrel and releases the unburned, or incompletely burned, powder, and creating muzzle flash (easily seen at night.) Christian. Well that is a question that deserves a long explanation, I’ll cover that in a moment but if you need a simple list now – here you go: As a competition shooter and law-enforcement officer, I’ve had my hands on revolvers quite a bit over the years. If it doesn't, something major is wrong. Generally, the larger the diameter change, the better the impact on the wound channel, which would increase the devastation, and therefore the stopping power of a given projectile, within reason. I picked up the box, , saw it labeled .357, and nearly paid for it. Not good for self defence or hunting. Being unjacketed lead it does require a thorough gun cleaning after a range session. 357 Magnum Ammunition Products including Top Brands like Sig Sauer, Hornady, Norma, CCI Ammunition and More! Keith, I think what they meant was that it’s only useful for range/target shooting.. ie a single use/purpose. Was the dog really rabid, or did you just not want to get bitten...?..a sharp kick in the jaw, if possible, turns most "rabid" dogs away...not saying you shouldn't protect yourself, but I've been bitten a couple times by dogs that were stirred up by adverse circumstances that had the dog protecting his turf, that did not need a lethal reaction..just sayin'... Only way to know if a dog is rabid is to have it tested (head sent off to state lab). Semi-Jacketed Rounds (SJ) have a harder shell around the shaft of the bullet, but not the tip. Also, the velocity can aid in things like impact energy, and in the case of some animals, the amount of shock to the system through a controversial topic called “hydrostatic shock theory”. In matters of self defense, your goal is to hit the target somewhere vital in order to neutralize the threat. Find a wide-ranging selection of handgun ammunition at Cabela's for your pistol or revolver. As a past gun dealer who also supplied the local police department and a gun owner and user since age 5 My experience has shown that the best all around bullet and weight for a .38/.357 mag is a 125 gr. I’m a beginner and was sold wrong ammo for my 357 magnum handgun ( still learning). Soft Pointed (SP) bullets have a jacket that leaves part of a soft bullet tip exposed. Our favorite guns and gear that we've tested and fully recommend. Gunpowder is designed with it's own oxidizers and burn in an expanding chamber. It is a good. Static ballistics are the numbers that are produced by the ammunition projectile in factory testing or by the standard pressures of the load in an optimum setup. With it’s low recoil there is little to disturb the sight picture. The first side of this debate says you cannot carry magnum ammunition in a revolver. It’s got less velocity and less energy potential compared to other rounds, and on the surface, it looks like a sort of anemic .357 Magnum, but the uniformity of expansion and the adequate penetration levels, as well as the relative consistency and reliability means this is a perfect pairing with your self-defense concealed carry type revolvers. In most cases, this is not ideal. (Always double check the markings on the gun/barrel) Expanding hollow point or soft point bullets are best for hunting because these bullets expand reliably and deliver the most kinetic energy into the animal. The 1934 introduction made the .38 Super for law enforcement use all but obsolete. Ammo companies can possibly put ammo in a box marked for a different caliber--again, that's extremely rare, but it can happen. 357 magnum; 357 sig; 380 auto; 38 special; 38 wad cutter; 38 super auto; 40 s&w; 44 mag. It is great for training or target. TMJ’s are used with higher velocity rounds and larger amounts of powder. Any thoughts from anybody would be greatly appreciated. I bought a box after reading several reviews speaking in its favor. reviews about performance , along with the Speer GD 135gr SB 357mag with less felt recoil. The best .357 magnum ammo is the ammunition that fits the specific need for you in the most efficient manner. We carry a wide variety of .357 Magnum ammunition. This sport puts reenactment into a competition form, in a sense, and challenges competitors to shoot old time cartridges in replica or other guns that were in use prior to 1899; with a specific set of challenges and loads. Light recoil gives better accuracy and also reduces developing bad shooting habits. He is focused on helping others protect themselves and their loved ones, and getting the most out of their time at the range. It is also a great handgun or lever gun cartridge for hunting of animals in the intermediate and large size range. A lot. This is a contender for the best 357 Magnum ammo for hunting of tough animals at moderate ranges due to the penetration potential and the hard copper projectile that offers extreme reliability in the mushrooming and diameter expansion. Upon entering a fluid medium, the heavier bullet will still have more energy to drill deeper than a lighter one. It is an excellent deer hunting and wild boar hunting round, and can reliably and humanely take down this animals, or similarly sized animals. It can encompass several aspects, but it essentially means the bullet’s efficiency at shedding wind in direct flight towards a target. For something already a little underpower, such as .380 Auto, an extra inch on the barrel can be huge for expansion. Best .38 Special & .357 Magnum Ammo [2021], Putting a .357 Magnum round in a .38 Special takes the firearm from. I was at a large gun store just north of Richmond, VA last Saturday and they had almost none of the common pistol caliber ammunition left. Mfg. Thanks team! Lighter bullets have less mass, but make up for it with increased velocity in defensive situations, but there is more danger of over-penetration. It shoots a 110 Grain bullet at a muzzle velocity of 1295 fps. What happened to the Speer GD mentions? .357 Magnum Ammo Inc. Signature Series, .357 Magnum, JHP, 125 Grain, 20 Rounds $ 17.99 $ 17.09 Don't anymore, to much recoil and blast (I hunt with a Ruger SRH in 454 Casull so I'm not shy of recoil) and it effects follow up shots. SJHP which I have used in situations of dire straights at 1250 ft. per second with very good terminal performance and minimal penetration as expected was enough to do the job without over penetration. Sellier & Bellot .357 Magnum 158gr Full Metal Jacket 50/Box is the ideal choice for recreational target shooting and training. Just what you need if you need more than one shot. The heavier the bullet the slower the velocity. That’s an interesting concept though, as the .357 Magnum cartridge is a versatile cartridge capable of many duties. Also, you say that heavier bullets have greater recoil, and lighter bullets have less recoil. This is what the state has on file for me to shoot. Make no mistake, there are other great rounds out there, and many loads that could easily replace the above list items, but for the money, and given the specific use of each of these loadouts, this list is a very good indicator of the stacked lineup of .357 Ammunition that exists on the market. is an excellent round. Hunters love the chase and take the opportunity to enjoy the outdoors. Firearms are made around those specifications and will safely chamber and shoot any ammo that it was specifically designed for. The larger the bullet weight, generally the larger the energy delivery (though there are some exceptions to this rule). Rarely, a gun manufacturer ships a gun in a box with an incorrect label. Don’t think that just because you can shoot .38 Special in a .357 Magnum that the reverse is true. C) Lastly, Ruger describes the rounds as having high-penetration of soft-targets, but also a shattering effect on hard surfaces. POTUS? The revolver would cease functioning. Generally, the faster the round is traveling, the better penetration there will tend to be, given the right mix of grain weight and velocity. Shipping: Free to High. Since you refer to your ".357 Magnum handgun," it sounds like you have a revolver, thus the problem ammo is probably .357 Sig. The bullets used for self defense are a bit more, is an excellent self-defense round. My thoughts and recommendations for picking the very best .357 Magnum or .38 Special ammo for your firearm. . Good to know it is still available. is a good starting point. It was a major shift towards performance when it came to matching the firepower on the streets against criminals and gangsters that were now starting to implement bullet proof vests and heavy steel car doors to shield themselves from police bullets. They run at a pricey $25-30 for a box of 20 rounds, and so far are the only ammo on the market to bear the Ruger name. New and experienced shooters usually look for the cheapest ammo to use for practice. The .357 S&W Magnum (9×33mmR), or simply .357 Magnum, is a revolver cartridge with a .357-inch (9.07 mm) bullet diameter. Any suggestions and thank you! Because it is solid lead, I thought they had stopped making these rounds. Match that to what's stamped on your gun--probably on the barrel of a revolver, and on the frame of a semi-auto. Thanks for putting this together. Just a picky technical point though. I am assuming that the jsp is meant for rifle and not handgun from reading your article.. please correct me if I’m wrong. Out of Stock Compare. Get proficient on YOUR time. The well-known, well-loved .357 Magnum can also be used easily for plinking or range training, and target shooting. It shoots a 158 Grain bullet at a muzzle velocity of 1235 fps. The rounds I recommend most for self defense include…, Remington Golden Saber .357 Magnum 125 Grain JHP, Remington HTP .38 Special+P 110 Grain SJHP. Parents should train children on all aspects of hunting before going out into t… So we have put together a list of the finest .357 ammunition loads for your different needs, and it should help you narrow down a style of ammunition or a set of characteristics that you should be looking for in an ammo for your use case. So imho for sub 30oz pistols train with 38 special +P or try a lightweight 357 grain and see if your hand can handle the recoil. Well, as long as you are using .38 Special ammo you can fire it safely in any .357 Magnum revolver. Bullet Weight: 180 Grains Famous gun industry figures including Elmer Keith (writer, hunter, tinkerer, sometimes thought leader) and D.B. Galileo proved all objects drop at the same rate. Back in the day, .38 Special +P 158 grain LSWCHP was the preferred round for carry in J-Frame snubnose revolvers. This bullet is heavy for a self-defense round. Satisfies most jurisdictional regulations for larger game hunting with the hollow point, all copper projectile and power/ballistics. But how do you pick the best ammo for your revolver? He just may not admit it. If the ammo doesn’t fit, it’s either the wrong ammo or the manufacturer of the ammo didn’t properly make the ammo. internal damage. I found out that the steel-framed Model 36 was not designed to use +P loads. • The lighter the bullet, the faster it will travel (load dependent). It is based upon Smith & … An all copper projectile retains the most weight of any projectile type, while offering excellent penetration through the bones, heavy muscle and thick hides of tough game like hogs, and other intermediate sized game. Case Type: Ducta-Bright 7a Nickel Plated Brass, Muzzle Velocity: 1400 fps Even with a two-handed grip in the trigger, it would not advance the cylinder I had to thoroughly clean it before it would function. Bullet drop is really based on the range a projectile has travelled according to it's velocity Gravity acts on all bullets the same, regardless of mass or "weight". Thanks, Best .357 Magnum Hunting Rounds. Buffalo Bore Ammunition 19J/20 Handgun 357 Rem Mag XPB 125 GR 20Box/12Case - $32.99 (Free S/H over $25, $8 Flat Rate on Ammo) $1.65 ppr $32.99. We’ve got a dedicated section for the AR-15 here. Why? It is still unproven, so far as I know. A) They are a youngster on the market, having only been released around late 2016. But, I like the round and, if I’m not mistaken, it once was the standard FBI load. It is an excellent self-defense round that is designed to work well in longer barrel guns for maximum velocity. Self Defense and Concealed carry for shooting out of a compact revolver or an ultra-lightweight .357 Magnum.

Making Promises Synonym, Dragon Warhammer Ge Tracker, Karena Rosario New Jersey, Christine Woods Instagram, Agile Scrum Presentation Ppt, Gsk Esprit Salary,

Leave a Reply